A single forecast can feel decisive while making every related business decision more fragile.

Want a deeper dive? Listen to my analysis on YouTube, Spotify, or Apple.

Scenario Planning

Would your leadership team rather be confidently wrong than openly uncertain? 

A recent McKinsey survey of over 200 senior leaders found that 53 percent believed scenario planning would protect their organizations from geopolitical shocks. That’s not surprising given the recent disruptions in oil, social unrest, and super intelligence. 

Yet fewer than 30 percent use scenario planning tools to make decisions. 

That gap reveals a problem. Leaders want to recognize the incredible uncertainty that exists today. But most planning systems reward unambiguous certainty. Revenue targets, hiring plans, inventory orders, and capital spending usually depend on one annual forecast. When assumptions fail, the ripple effect is felt far and wide across the organization. 

That’s the challenge and opportunity with scenario planning. 

I helped create the scenario planning methodology when I was leading the strategy group at HP in Silicon Valley. One of the toughest things in the approach was the subtle requirement that leaders admit something seemingly antithetical to leadership itself: We must admit we really don’t know how things will unfold. 

Uncertainty Feels Threatening 

A study in the journal Nature helps explain why uncertainty is so uncomfortable. Researchers asked participants to play a computer game in which rocks sometimes concealed snakes. Finding one resulted in a mild electric shock. 

Stress was highest when the odds of a shock were 50 percent. Participants felt less stress, however, when they knew the shock was coming or knew they were safe. A bad outcome with certainty felt easier to manage than a choice without a clear answer. 

During my time at HP, I worked across the company’s business units using an adaptation of Royal Dutch Shell’s well-known scenario-planning approach. Usually, teams develop several credible future scenarios, then spend time debating which one’s most likely to occur. Once they select a winner, they’re back to planning around a single answer. 

Leaders’ added pressure involves the expectation to deliver strategic direction. So, a clear forecast looks like competence. Hedging around scenarios looks like wishy washy leadership. 

Single Scenarios Create Future Risk 

The problem shows up most clearly in the annual planning process. A company selects one target revenue number. The approved forecast then drives hiring, purchasing, and investment. A major shift in tariffs, supply, demand, or regulation can upend assumptions and the activities built upon them. 

I agree with the conclusion of the McKinsey survey which cautioned against assigning probabilities to scenarios. That’s because outcomes are too difficult to predict. Instead, separate decisions into actions to take now, risks to watch, and strategies that apply accross every scenario. 

This all changes the purpose of planning. Leaders no longer have to put a stake in the ground around which future will occur. Instead, they need to identify alternative scenarios, the factors influencing them, and how to approach things using contingencies. 

In May 2025, for example, U.S. tariffs on Chinese goods changed dramatically within a matter of weeks. During an investor call, Walmart CFO John David Rainey declined to give a profit forecast for the upcoming quarter. The company could not produce a range narrow enough “that it was even credible.” 

Rainey instead described different scenarios. Walmart expected to meet its full-year targets under the most likely ones. But not if tariffs returned to their prior peak. The company then reduced orders for certain higher-priced seasonal products to limit the risk of being stuck with inventory that customers wouldn’t buy at higher prices. 

Build Choices Into Your Planning Process 

Scenario planning works when it expands today’s choices. Here’s how to use it: 

    • Describe several alternative futures. Identify the external forces that could disrupt your business. Describe future scenarios that differ in meaningful ways. Play around with a 2×2 matrix with different variables and you’ll likely end up with four distinct scenarios. 
    • Explore implications. For each future, examine what you would do differently with hiring, inventory, and other major commitments. Then, determine what choices remain the same across all scenarios. Those are decisions you can make now and will likely be stable into the future. 
    • Set warning signs. Decide what observable changes in the external environment would trigger each scenario to become real. Track these triggers and adapt strategy as a given scenario unfolds. 

You can’t predict the future. But you can track how it unfolds and respond in real time. That’s leadership. 

I publish Leapfrogging the Headlines to help leaders cut through the noise, gain clarity on what’s happening, and make smarter decisions. Subscribe below to get each issue delivered free.

Leapfrogging The Headlines

Join 30,000+ other leaders