
When does a scrappy prototype become a customer deception?
The question matters because nearly every early product uses shortcuts. It’s smart to promote features to gauge interest before they actually exist. And your ultimate vision may be years ahead of your release schedule.
Elizabeth Holmes is back in the movie You Can See Everything, the A24 documentary from Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim. I just saw it.
The film follows Holmes beginning 34 days before she reports to federal prison. She continues to profess her innocence and even talks openly about her desire to get back into the medical diagnostics game.
Holmes told investors that Theranos’s diagnostic could perform a full range of laboratory tests using a single drop of blood. According to the SEC, the company’s device could complete only a small number of tests, while most patient samples were processed using modified machines made by other companies.
The Theranos story highlights an important distinction every founder needs to understand: the difference between a minimal viable product and fraud. An MVP is a product that’s ready to be sold and go to market. But it can’t misrepresent the capabilities that it contains that people believe they’re buying. It can represent a vision of what’s possible or coming in the future through upgrades or software updates.
MVPs versus frauds
In 1999, Zappos tested whether people would buy shoes online. They photographed shoes in local stores and listed them on their website. When customers placed orders, they returned to the store, purchased the shoes, and shipped them.
Customers didn’t know there wasn’t a warehouse with inventory. Zappos’ hidden manual process didn’t deceive customers. They received the shoes they ordered. And the company was able to test whether or not people would actually buy shoes online to validate their business model.
Nikola presents the opposite case. In 2018, founder Trevor Milton posted a video that appeared to show an electric Nikola truck driving down a road. According to federal prosecutors, the prototype didn’t have a motor or gears. In fact, it was towed uphill and filmed rolling down in a way that made it look like it was driving down a level road. Investors and customers lined up based on this deception.
In both the Theranos and Nikola cases, the simulated features were the capabilities being promoted and sold. And they didn’t yet exist.
Vision versus reality
An MVP is a fully functional product designed to satisfy customer needs at their most basic level. It’s used to test assumptions about whether the product is good enough, whether a market exists, and whether people are actually willing to pay.
The problem for leaders comes into play when the marketing and positioning of the MVP is fudged to make it sound better than it really is. And doing this can have a downward spiral effect on the company’s values and ethics.
A 2015 study published in the Journal of Applied Psychology gave participants repeated opportunities to cheat for money. When temptation began small and increased gradually, participants cheated at twice the rate of those who faced a sudden temptation. Each minor justification made the next one feel more acceptable.
AI makes the gap easier to fill, and hide
AI can now produce polished interfaces, convincing prototypes, and a confident pitch in hours. The gap between the professional look of your website, the features you promote, your dashboards, and other promises versus what actually exists can easily grow into a real disconnect between your marketing and product reality.
Less extreme versions of this can appear inside companies. A team demonstrates an AI agent using only inputs and data it handles well. Or you only selectively report on the metrics that look good, omitting the failures.
In both these cases, the problem is when customers, boards, or investors commit money or trust based on limited data and a storyline that hides assumptions and risk.
Build MVPs that deliver the compelling truth
Use three steps to keep experimentation honest without slowing innovation:
-
- Connect reality to decision-making. Be clear about what exists versus what’s part of your future vision when selling and going for funding.
- Label what’s real. Mark every feature as working, manual, simulated, or planned, and make the labels visible to your customers, executives, and investors.
- Reveal gaps. Disclose what’s missing to move your MVP to your fully featured solution, and how you’ll fill those gaps.
AI lets teams create products that look real faster than ever, which means disclosure becomes more important than ever. Your MVP can be scrappy, but it still needs to tell the truth.
I publish Leapfrogging the Headlines to help leaders cut through the noise, gain clarity on what’s happening, and make smarter decisions. Subscribe below to get each issue delivered free.

Join 30,000+ other leaders